Careless-driving records: PSNI says checking circumstances would take 1,000 hours
Why the headline number is not a pet-distraction count
A freedom-of-information request about driving without proper control and potential distractions from animals prompted PSNI to disclose a striking administrative obstacle: examining the detailed circumstances behind relevant motoring records would require more than 1,000 hours of manual work.
The request, FOI/14301, covered calendar years 2022 to 2024. It sought figures for cautions, fixed penalties, prosecutions, offence details and accompanying officer notes, including whether an animal inside a vehicle had contributed to loss of control. PSNI’s response, issued on 6 May 2025, refused the combined request on cost grounds.
The force said there were more than 6,000 records in the relevant fixed-penalty and prosecution-referral pool for the detailed review. This is not evidence that 6,000 motorists were distracted by pets. It is not a verified count of one specific offence code either. The disclosure uses that scale to explain why checking contextual notes was not feasible within the FOI cost limit.
Different law, different codes, different outcomes
The original requester referred to the CD10 code. PSNI explained that Northern Ireland uses different offence codes from England and Wales and offered locally applicable descriptions, including driving without due care and attention or without reasonable consideration, not having proper control and careless driving. The requester then clarified that the first description was acceptable.
That exchange is more than a technical detail. If researchers apply the wrong code, they risk comparing unlike offences or presenting an apparently precise trend that has been built from inconsistent categories. It also matters whether a dataset counts offences detected, fixed penalties, prosecution referrals or final court outcomes.
PSNI separately stated that it does not issue formal cautions for motoring offences. That response should not be converted into a claim that every suspected instance results in a penalty or prosecution; enforcement decisions and outcomes require their own evidence.
The gap between a charge and its circumstances
An offence record may contain a formal category that can be counted automatically, alongside descriptive notes that explain what an officer observed. A request for the first can be quick; a request asking whether a dog or another animal contributed to the event may require a person to read narrative evidence and decide how to classify it.
PSNI estimated at least ten minutes per record for more than 6,000 relevant files, exceeding 1,000 hours. The important discovery is the difficulty of retrieving a reliable subcategory from the material held—not the prevalence of animal-related incidents.
Because the original request combined several questions, one expensive component could bring the whole request beyond the statutory threshold. PSNI advised that a refined request for certain numerical elements might be possible, even though detailed note searches could not be brought within cost.
The actual road-safety guidance for motorists with animals
The Highway Code advises drivers to ensure animals are suitably restrained so that they cannot distract the driver or injure occupants during sudden braking. The published rule mentions a suitable harness, carrier, cage or guard as possible solutions.
This is useful safety context but not evidence that any particular crash in Northern Ireland was caused by an unsecured dog. An observed breach of safe practice, a careless-driving allegation and a proven causal factor in a collision are separate propositions requiring separate evidence.
In practical terms a driver should prevent animals moving around the cabin, make sure restraints are appropriate to the animal and vehicle, and avoid interacting with pets in a way that diverts attention from the road. A specific alleged offence depends on the facts and the applicable Northern Ireland law.
What the next information request should ask
The strongest follow-up would separate machine-readable counts from free-text searches. Ask for annual totals for the clarified Northern Ireland offence descriptions, and distinguish penalties issued, prosecution referrals and disposals where existing administrative tables permit. If the authority maintains any independently coded distraction category, request the category definitions and annual counts.
PSNI specifically indicated that parts of requests 2, 3, 4 and 7 might be answerable within cost through refinement. It said a manual search of the note material in requests 5 and 6 could not be refined sufficiently. Those boundaries should shape subsequent reporting, rather than submitting the same broad question again.
The verified conclusion is that the force does not readily produce a pet-related careless-driving total from its relevant records. That gap limits public analysis; it does not prove a hidden epidemic or an enforcement failure. Any claim about frequency would need a defensible count, clear definitions and a comparable period.
Sources and methodology
This report examines the published PSNI freedom-of-information response and the additional official material linked below. Figures are attributed to their original reporting periods; no new response, interview or primary-data exercise is claimed. Conclusions described as questions or possible implications are analysis, not established findings.
- https://www.psni.police.uk/foi-disclosure-log/driving-without-proper-control-vehicle-offences
- https://www.gov.uk/guidance/the-highway-code/rules-about-animals-47-to-58
- https://www.gov.uk/guidance/the-highway-code/general-rules-techniques-and-advice-for-all-drivers-and-riders-103-to-158
- https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/foi/freedom-of-information-and-environmental-information-regulations/section-12-requests-where-the-cost-of-compliance-exceeds-the-appropriate-limit/
- https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2000/36/contents