← PureCar News

NI car park penalties: 1,057 at Bishop Street and the hidden 2024 data break

Published
FEATURE
NI car park penalties: 1,057 at Bishop Street and the hidden 2024 data break

Parking records reveal more than a list of ticket hotspots. One official disclosure shows 1,057 penalties at Derry’s Bishop Street car park in 2023, and an April 2024 change that makes later comparisons particularly hazardous.

What the figures really cover

The Department for Infrastructure received an information request seeking annual penalty-charge notices for individual off-street car parks from January 2019 to December 2024. Its response, DFI/2025-0180 issued on 8 May 2025, provided an attachment recording notices between 1 May 2022 and 31 December 2024. It explained that earlier records had not been retained under its disposal schedule. The absence of 2019–April 2022 data is therefore not a year of zero tickets; it is a gap in the disclosed dataset.

The attachment breaks entries down by named location and contravention code. In the 2023 section, Bishop Street car park in Derry shows 1,057 notices, Eden Street in Enniskillen 949, Lancaster Street in Belfast 724, and Shore Road East in Enniskillen 677. Those figures are raw issue counts, not estimates or appeals outcomes.

Off-street car park2023 PCNs shown
Bishop Street, Derry1,057
Eden Street, Enniskillen949
Lancaster Street, Belfast724
Shore Road East, Enniskillen677

PureCar selected those four named locations from the 2023 pages for comparison; this is not presented as a proven top-four ranking of every car park in Northern Ireland. That would require a complete uniform dataset covering all operators. It would also be wrong to label any of them the most dangerous, unfair or expensive: PCNs provide none of those measures.

A particularly revealing split at Bishop Street

The 2023 Bishop Street line contains 188 notices under Code 82, 770 under Code 83, one under Code 71, 20 under Code 86 and 78 under Code 87, totalling 1,057. Official nidirect guidance defines Code 82 as remaining after paid parking time expires, whereas Code 83 concerns parking without clearly displaying a valid pay-and-display ticket or holding a valid cashless parking event. Code 86 concerns bay markings, Code 87 disabled spaces and Code 71 charging places.

Bishop Street code (2023)PCNsShare
83 — no valid displayed ticket/cashless event77072.8%
82 — paid time expired18817.8%
87 — disabled space787.4%
86 — outside bay markings201.9%
71 — EV charging place10.1%

The key result is the contrast between 770 Code 83 tickets and 188 Code 82 tickets. Treating both categories as “drivers overstaying” would fundamentally misreport what the records say. The 72.8% figure is calculated as 770 divided by 1,057, rounded to one decimal place. It describes the recorded contravention category, not the underlying reason a motorist failed to present a valid payment entitlement.

Code 83 can raise different practical questions from overstaying: was a ticket purchased but not displayed, was an electronic payment event properly recorded, or did a motorist simply fail to pay? The published table cannot distinguish those circumstances. It provides recorded code counts, not evidence that any signs, machines or payment systems were faulty.

The date that breaks a simple trend chart

The response explains that the Department had provided off-street enforcement for eight councils until March 2024. From 1 April 2024 the councils assumed responsibility for enforcement in their own off-street car parks. DfI retained responsibility for the three charged Belfast Park & Ride facilities at Eastside, Northside and Great George’s Street.

That change is essential. A fall or disappearance in DfI’s 2024 local-council car park figures might reflect a transfer of enforcement responsibility, not an improvement in motorists’ compliance. Anyone building a headline such as “parking fines collapse in 2024” by comparing the DfI tables without accounting for that transfer risks mistaking an administrative boundary for a behavioural trend.

For a proper 2024 comparison, a reporter would need the local councils’ records for April–December, confirm consistent definitions and marry them to the DfI January–March data. The public disclosure does not supply a seamlessly combined series for all those councils. PureCar therefore does not calculate a three-year increase or decline from the attachment alone.

More penalties do not automatically mean a worse car park

A busy central car park with hundreds of spaces and high turnover may generate more tickets than a small facility even when a smaller percentage of its users breach the rules. Counts need a denominator: occupied space-hours, paid parking sessions, capacity or comparable visits. The EIR attachment provides none of these. It also does not give how many PCNs were cancelled, paid early, contested or ultimately upheld.

Another difficulty is the difference between ticket issue date and final outcome. A PCN can be challenged and may later be cancelled; a count of notices issued does not mean an identical count of enforceable final penalties. Reporting them as guaranteed fine revenue would be unjustified. Revenue also depends on the charge amount, discount rules, payment and cancellation outcomes.

A carefully designed comparison would match car parks with similar capacities, parking terms, opening hours and enforcement arrangements, then examine offence categories. Without that, any “worst parking hotspot” list describes activity volume, not the chance that an individual driver will be ticketed.

What motorists can do with the codes

The first useful step after receiving a PCN is to read its actual code and location. For Code 82, compare the paid expiry time and recorded observation. For Code 83, preserve the physical ticket where applicable or electronic payment confirmation. For Code 86, record the position of wheels relative to marked bays. For Code 87, the circumstances and valid Blue Badge display rules matter. The official nidirect pages explain the formal meanings, and there is an online route to view evidence and challenge a ticket.

Photographs of the bay, signs and pay machines can help document a dispute, but no photograph automatically invalidates a penalty. Drivers should follow the deadlines on the notice and use the relevant authority’s current procedure — especially for a council-run car park now outside DfI enforcement.

The most valuable unanswered question is not which car park has the highest raw ticket count. It is whether a small number of locations repeatedly produce an unusually high rate of specific contraventions, even after adjusting for visitors and capacity. The published response gives a strong starting point for that investigation, but stops before providing the necessary denominators or appeal outcomes.

A simple test of what a hotspot label hides

Imagine Car Park A issues 1,000 PCNs while serving 500,000 parking sessions, and Car Park B issues 300 against only 20,000 sessions. Their hypothetical notice rates are 0.2% and 1.5% respectively. The site issuing fewer tickets has the much higher rate. Those are deliberately invented illustration numbers, not DfI statistics, and show why volume rankings alone cannot identify where motorists are most likely to receive a notice.

The same principle applies to duration of stay. A facility with two-hour limits and high turnover is not directly comparable to an all-day park-and-ride car park. Pay-and-display rules, payment methods, permitted classes of vehicle and disabled-bay provision can differ. Contravention-code breakdowns can start to reveal patterns, but only when those operational differences are described alongside the data.

Bishop Street also illustrates the value of inspecting the raw line rather than relying on a press-release summary: its five displayed code columns add exactly to the reported 1,057 total. At Lancaster Street the 2023 line gives a separate total of 724, and at Eden Street it gives 949. PureCar checked these directly against the year-labelled attachment rather than combining neighbouring rows or carrying 2022 figures into 2023. The document groups locations and codes closely, making careless transcription a genuine source of risk.

The most defensible next stage is therefore a joined dataset with the relevant councils, consistent car-park identifiers, monthly notices, the number of spaces and completed parking sessions. That could establish whether a cluster of code-83 issues is unusual, rather than merely common at a busy car park.

Sources and methodology

PureCar examined the original published government response and cross-checked the interpretations against the official guidance linked below. Calculations are derived from the published figures; they are not new data supplied privately to PureCar. The response dates and coverage are stated in the article because historical disclosures must not be represented as newly released information.

SOURCES

Sources & further reading

www.infrastructure-ni.gov.uk www.infrastructure-ni.gov.uk www.infrastructure-ni.gov.uk www.nidirect.gov.uk www.nidirect.gov.uk www.nidirect.gov.uk www.nidirect.gov.uk www.nidirect.gov.uk www.nidirect.gov.uk
CARS FOR SALE

Find Your Next Motor

Explore NI
Find Your Next Car Search Northern Ireland Cars Browse cars for sale across Northern Ireland